On 16 July 2021, Hakainde Hichilema was the opposition leader, a month from the election that would make him president. He posted a table headed "Salaries Comparison" and wrote:

"As we talk about cost of living comparison, let's also talk about salaries. HH aka Bally #Time4Change." A civil servant: K4,000 in Zambia, K30,000 in South Africa. A miner: K5,000 against K35,000. A doctor: K18,000 against K75,000. Minimum wage: K1,200 against K3,800.

It drew 46,400 reactions, 1,900 shares and 17,800 comments.

One comment reads like the whole country's verdict. Wazi Chiyokoma Nseluka wrote: "How far with this agenda? 😂😂" It is a joke and a challenge at once, and five years into Hichilema's presidency — he began his second term on 1 September — it is still the right question. The thread itself sits behind a Facebook login, so this article draws on a sample of around 70 comments from it, covering the whole five years from July 2021 to this week — not all 17,800, and several of the sampled comments are cut short where Facebook hides the rest, so only what is visible is quoted.

Hakainde Hichilema's Facebook post, 16 July 2021
Hakainde Hichilema's Facebook post, 16 July 2021

What the thread says

The thread is a five-year argument, and the hard questions were there from the first day. Harold Banda asked the one that matters most:

"Seems to be a good analysis though. Are you yourself going to increase to the same levels once voted in?"

Alice asked:

"Does this mean our salaries will go to 30pin? Asking for Anna Chandwe 🤣🤣🤣"

Fredrick Kelvin Bwalya Chabala put it more bluntly:

"Ask nkweteko are you going to be paying the civil servants south African salaries?"

Tommy Kadz asked a question the post never answered:

"Are these gross or net amounts?"

Not everyone bought the comparison. Bomba Wilfred wrote:

"Civil servant is too broad a term specific comparisons. Let's say for instance police officers here in Zambia and in South Africa🇿🇦"

King George II called it

"comparing a bag of cotton with a pocket of cement. Ba Bally. 😂 😂"

Tim Kaya wrote:

"Comparing South Africa to Zambia z like Comparing you to Edgar Lungu."

Kudos Berry wanted a plan, not a table:

"Tell us the mechanisms you'll put in place to better our economy and stop comparing .... Let's focus."

The table also found defenders. Prince Innocent, writing from South Africa, said:

"Living in SA I can safely approve the figures are correct. Infact the minimum wage is R3,500 (Approximately K5,250 @current rate)."

His figure is higher than the R2,500 the table implied — which is the point: even a defender put the South African minimum above the table's number. Zolani Maramba, a South African who lived in Zambia for about six years, said he was shocked by teachers' salaries. And two replies undercut the Zambian column itself.

Chakatazya Aretha wrote:

"Miners where I am right now are getting a k2000"

— K2,000, not the K5,000 in the table. Angy Favoured Nzala added:

"Contractors K1000."

Both are one commenter's word, not verified figures, but they are a reminder that the post's Zambian column was never sourced either.

Then the thread goes quiet, and the later comments read like people returning to check. Kasonde Mumbi wrote 47 weeks ago:

"The main reason I voted. But limbi January kuti fyachitika" — the main reason I voted, but wait, let it happen in January.

David Bwale, two years ago:

"Bally wakulekafe😂😂one shi promise aka bashi hope😄😄" — Bally is one to just watch*; one [father of] promises aka [father of] hope.

Kelly Lukeshi, a year ago, quoted the Glorious Band:

"Ukulanda kwalyanguka" — talking is easy — "see now."

Daniel Banda, 46 weeks ago:

"You better...cause folks won't let you keep that seat if you dont pull it off..."

And John Sakala, two years ago:

"Anyway we will wait for 2026."

The sharpest return is Wazi Chiyokoma Nseluka himself. Sixteen weeks ago he wrote:

"Ba yama aba okay niba scammer maaa 😂😂😂😂😂" — these guys are scammers.

Forty-one minutes ago he came back with the line that opens this article: "How far with this agenda?"

The thread has become a place people revisit — Isaac Mwape Sakeni has dropped in three times across two years, each time with little more than laughing emojis — and the mood of the revisits is unmistakable. The newest comments are not about the table any more. They are about mealie meal — "Ubungafye daddy 12.5kg ni k335," wrote Tithamenji Phiri a year ago — and about the K500 award: "Boi Laura Chingwe ufola shinga inonshita after the K500 increment across the board??" asked Hastings J Mulenga, how much are you earning now, after the K500 increment? Felix J Ngulube, a year ago, put the current figure at "seven pin" — K7,000 — which matches the government's own defence of the K700 award in February, when it described the rise as about 10 percent for someone on K7,000.

And Hezron Sinyangwe, a year ago, drew the conclusion the table pointed to all along:

"So a miner in SA gets twice the salary of a Zambian doctor. And am here studying fi medicine naya mukwimba amabwe ku SA" — and here I am studying medicine; I might as well go and dig stones in South Africa.

Were the numbers right? At the Bank of Zambia's first-half 2021 average of about K1.52 to the rand, the South African column implied roughly R19,700 a month for a civil servant, R23,000 for a miner, R49,300 for a doctor and R2,500 for a minimum-wage worker. Two rows were roughly right and two were wide of the mark, and both errors made the gap look smaller than it was.

South Africa's minimum wage in 2021 was R21.69 an hour, according to the Department of Employment and Labour, or about R4,230 a month: the table implied R2,500. A South African medical officer at Grade 1 earned R821,205 a year in 2021, according to a Free State health department advert of that July — about R68,400 a month, against the R49,300 implied. The miners' figure was the closest: the Minerals Council puts the average entry-level package at about R22,500 a month. On the Zambian side, the legal floor for a general worker was K1,698.60 a month, not K1,200. His K5,000 for miners and K18,000 for doctors could not be checked against any published source.

What has changed since? On pay, the government can point to a record no previous administration can match: an increase for civil servants every year since 2022: 12 percent in 2022, 10.5 percent in 2023, K550 across the board in 2024, K500 in 2025, K700 in 2026. The minimum wage for general workers rose from K1,698.60 to K2,313.10 in January 2024, where it has stayed. The floor has stayed at K2,313.10 a month since January 2024, under Statutory Instrument No. 48 of 2023, and no increase took effect in January 2026. In the mines, Konkola Copper Mines awarded 13 percent for 2026 and Mopani 12 percent. For doctors, the story is harder: residents recruited in June reported for duty unpaid, and only on 31 July were 72 of the 77 affected doctors on the payroll, according to their association.

But the increases have not kept up with prices. According to the Zambia Statistics Agency, prices have risen 129 percent since January 2020, while a civil servant's basic pay has risen 59 percent; The Zambian Economist's analysis finds a civil servant on K13,000 a month has lost about 30 percent of the real value of their pay since then. Inflation has been tamed — 22.8 percent in the first half of 2021, according to the Bank of Zambia, against 6.3 percent in October this year, according to ZamStats — but a lower rate does not bring prices back down. And the gap with South Africa is still more than three to one at the bottom: the minimum wage there is now R30.23 an hour, about R5,895 a month, or roughly K7,310 at today's rate, against Zambia's K2,313.10. A South African medical officer now earns about R83,400 a month (roughly K103,500). What a Zambian doctor or miner earns could not be established from any published source. That absence is itself part of the story.

The cost of living tells the same story more plainly. During the 2021 campaign, Hichilema promised a 25-kilogramme bag of mealie meal at K50. The highest price when he took office was K120, according to the Daily Revelation; the national average in October this year was K235.86, according to ZamStats — twice the price at inauguration, nearly five times the promised K50. Petrol was K17.62 a litre when he took office; it is K33.06 this month, according to the Energy Regulation Board. The kwacha is steadier than the K22.60 to the dollar of July 2021 — K20.55 on 11 November, according to Finnhub — but steadier is not stronger.

So, how far with this agenda? The fair answer gives the government its due: pay has risen every year since 2022, inflation is inside the Bank of Zambia's target band, and the IMF expects 5.6 percent growth this year. But the honest answer is what the commenter was getting at: the gap Hichilema's table described is still there, in almost the same shape. A Zambian on the minimum wage still earns less than a third of a South African on theirs. A bag of mealie meal costs twice what it did when he took office. A doctor who answered the government's call waited two months to reach the payroll. The table was a campaign weapon in 2021. In 2026 it reads as a scorecard — and on that scorecard, the president has moved the numbers, just not far enough for the people in them.