On Wednesday 11 November, eighteen people who have been in custody since 14 August were due to have their main question answered in the Lusaka High Court. The hearing was listed to start at 09:00. It never got that far.
The eighteen — led by Brian Mundubile and Makebi Zulu — face alleged treason, sedition and terrorism-related offences, according to Zambia 24 and Diamond Media, who reported on the hearing on 11 November. They are asking the court for bail. That sounds straightforward. Treason makes it anything but.
Bail, in ordinary language, is when a person charged with a crime asks the court to let them go home while they wait for trial, usually on conditions the court sets. For most offences, the court can say yes. Treason is different: under Zambian law, it is ordinarily a non-bailable offence, which means the usual route to bail is closed. That is why this case is not an ordinary bail application.
So the applicants have turned to the Constitution itself. They sued the Attorney General, Mulilo Kabesha, and the Director of Public Prosecutions, Gilbert Phiri, arguing that keeping them locked up violates their constitutional rights, according to Zambia 24. The Constitution is the highest law in the country, so if detention breaches it, the court can order a release even where the ordinary bail rules would not allow one. That is what "constitutional bail" means: bail asked for under the Constitution, rather than under the ordinary rules.
The case has already cleared one hurdle. On Tuesday 10 November, the three-judge panel hearing it — Justices Derrick Mulenga, Davies Chibwili and Ireen Wishimanga, according to Zambia Monitor — dismissed the State's objection to the way the application had been filed. The judges ruled that no law or court rule stops an aggrieved person from seeking constitutional bail in that way, Zambia Monitor reported. That decision cleared the way for the hearing itself.
But when the hearing opened on Wednesday, the substance — whether the eighteen should be released — was still not reached. First, the Attorney General asked for a delay, citing another court matter. Then the Director of Public Prosecutions raised a fresh preliminary issue, asking the court to strike out paragraphs in the applicants' affidavit in reply that relate to video footage on a flash disk showing a raid at Makebi Zulu's home. Defence lawyer Sakwiba Sikota told the court the State was seeking to have that video evidence expunged, according to Zambia 24.
Some of those words need unpacking. A preliminary objection is a side question that the court has to settle before it can deal with the main question — in this case, whether certain paragraphs and the video should form part of the case at all. An affidavit is a written statement that a person swears is true, and an affidavit in reply is the applicants' written answer to the State's response. To expunge evidence is to remove it from the court record, so that the judge cannot rely on it. And a flash disk is simply a small device for storing computer files — here, the video of the raid.
What happens next is a matter of order. The court must first decide the preliminary issue about the video and the paragraphs in the affidavit. Only after that can it hear the substance: whether the eighteen should be released on constitutional bail. No new hearing date had been reported by the evening of 11 November, and nothing in the reports so far says whether bail will be granted or refused. This article makes no prediction about the outcome.
One confusion is worth clearing up. This constitutional bail case is separate from the sedition case against Mundubile and Zulu, which was adjourned to Monday 16 November. The two cases involve some of the same people, but they are different proceedings, with different questions before the court.
For readers following the case, the thing to watch is not the arguments about procedure, important as they are, but the day the court finally reaches the substance. That is when the judges will have to answer the question at the heart of it: whether keeping these eighteen people in custody since August breaches the Constitution.