The Director of Public Prosecutions has dropped the case in which former Patriots for Economic Progress leader Sean Tembo was charged with using insulting language against President Hakainde Hichilema.

The DPP, Gilbert Phiri, entered a nolle prosequi — a formal notice discontinuing the case — before High Court Judge Davies Chibwili, sitting as Lusaka Chief Resident Magistrate, on Friday. State prosecutor Michael Nundwe told the court the DPP's office had filed the notice under Section 81 of the Criminal Procedure Code. The notice came just before Judge Chibwili was to rule on whether Mr Tembo had a case to answer. The judge admitted the nolle and discharged Mr Tembo. The Zambian Observer reported the decision on Friday evening.

Mr Tembo had faced two counts of insulting language under Section 179 of the Penal Code, arising from Facebook posts dated 27 August and 17 October 2023. He was arrested in November 2023. The case had been running for three years.

The first thing to understand is what a nolle prosequi is — and what it is not. It is a discharge, not an acquittal. The DPP retains the authority to re-institute the charges at any time, and Mr Tembo remains liable to re-arrest on the same charges. He walked out of court a free man on Friday. He did not walk out cleared.

The second thing is what the DPP did not say. No published report gives a reason for the decision. It would be wrong to guess at one — whether the case was weak, whether it was a matter of policy, or whether something else altogether lay behind it. The record is silent, and this newspaper will not fill it.

The third thing is what the decision does not settle. Mr Tembo had separately petitioned the High Court in November 2025 to strike down Section 179 as unconstitutional, arguing that it defines no offence and is contrary to Article 18(8) of the Constitution. He also sought an out-of-court settlement through alternative dispute resolution early this year. The nolle decides none of that. Section 179 remains on the books, and the constitutional question remains open for another day — and another defendant.

It is also worth being clear about what this case is not. It is not the treason case. Mr Tembo is not one of the 18 people held on treason charges whose bail hearing resumes on Monday, and this nolle has nothing to do with that case. The two matters involve different charges, different years and different courts, and they should not be confused.

The decision will be read in different ways. Supporters of the government will say it shows restraint — a prosecution service willing to drop a case it no longer wishes to pursue. Critics will ask why a three-year case was brought at all, and whether the law should exist in the first place. Both readings are legitimate. What is not legitimate is to pretend the case is over. It is paused, not finished. The DPP can bring it back. And the law that made it possible is still there, waiting for the next Facebook post.