The State has opened its case against bail for the 18 people held on treason charges, telling the High Court that the length of their detention so far is not, on its own, a reason to free them.
Director of Public Prosecutions Gilbert Phiri and Attorney-General Mulilo Kabesha told the three-judge panel that the gravity of the charges and the scale of the investigations justified the time taken to bring the accused before court, according to Lusaka Times. Detention of 60 or even 90 days, they said, could not automatically be called unreasonable.
To support that position, Mr Phiri reached back into Zambia's treason history. He cited The People v Njapau of 1967 and The People v Edward Jack Shamwana and 12 others, telling the court that constitutional bail had not been granted in either matter, and urged the judges not to depart from that position.
The defence answered with a statute rather than a precedent. Lawyers Milner Katolo, Sakwiba Sikota and Chifumu Banda told the court that Section 55 of the Anti-Terrorism Act requires suspects arrested under that law to be brought before court within 48 hours, that any extension needs a judge's approval, and that detention may not run beyond 45 days.
Mr Katolo then set out how long each group of applicants had been held. Three of them, arrested on 1 August, had spent 72 days in custody by 12 October, when the petition was filed. Business executive Harry Findlay, arrested on 4 August, had been held for more than 68 days. Mr Mundubile and Mr Zulu, arrested on 27 August, had spent more than 47 days in detention by 13 October. The seriousness of the charges and the need for further investigation, Mr Katolo said, could not override the constitutional right to be brought before court within a reasonable time.
Before either side could fully test those arguments, the panel ruled on what evidence would stay on the record. The judges struck out paragraphs six and 21 of the applicants' affidavit. Paragraph six raised a claim that officers had confiscated certificates for training in Russia on 1 August, while paragraph 21 went beyond the issues raised by the DPP.
On other points the State lost ground. The court kept the material about Mr Mundubile and Mr Zulu's stay at a United Nations facility, which the State had cited to portray the two as flight risks. The applicants said they sought refuge there because they feared for their lives after an alleged incident involving gunfire, and the court held that the allegation was relevant.
The judges also kept on the record video said to show state agents breaking into Mr Mundubile's home in Kabulonga, relying on Section 9 of the Electronic Communications and Transactions Act of 2021, which recognises electronic evidence.
The hearing stalled before the core submissions were finished, after Mr Phiri raised concerns about security arrangements and lock-up times at the facility where the applicants are held. The panel adjourned the matter to Monday, when it will weigh the DPP's treason precedents against the 45-day limit written into the Anti-Terrorism Act.
The 18 applicants, who are being held at Mukobeko Maximum Security Correctional Facility in Kabwe, have petitioned the court against the Attorney-General and the DPP, saying their continued detention violates their constitutional rights. None of them has been convicted. Mr Mundubile and Mr Zulu also face a separate sedition case, with a bail hearing set for Monday 16 November. The Zambian Observer reported on Friday that the same bench had delivered its ruling on the disputed affidavit material.